by Peter Williams

The overhang finally came into mainstream media play this week. The 1 News poll on Tuesday night predictably saw the National Party vote slip back from its outlier of 32% last week to 29, just one ahead of Labour. The three points that the Nats lost went straight to potential coalition partners Act and NZ First, who between them reached 22%.

The Maori Party has, by design, completely collapsed their party vote to 0.1% but are now on track to win four seats, all of which will be overhang because their party vote share is under 0.8%, the threshold to qualify for a seat won in an electorate.

So we are on track for the largest parliament ever – and that’s before we factor in an overhang from the National party. And in the 1 News analysis of the poll earlier this week, the machinations of something that has been quite obvious for some time were finally being discussed.

What has been staring us in the face for a long time – that is National winning more electorates than its party vote entitles it to – is now out in the open. The Herald went through each of the 71 electorates seat by seat and reckoned that National could win up to 40 of them. Remember, a 30% party vote means 36 seats. But whichever way you look at it, a party vote for National will be wasted. Finance Minister Nicola Willis won’t be back in parliament.

So the new parliament is shaping up to have nearly 130 members, possibly 10 more than specified, meaning one or other block will need 65 for a majority, and the Opportunity Party is still lurking. It was down to 6% in the 1 News poll, but back up to 7.2 in Thursday’s RNZ Reid Research, a poll which has the left block of Labour, Greens and Opportunity winning easily on percentages with 52.3% of the vote, with the four seats of the Maori Party on top of that. Even a four-seat National overhang couldn’t overcome that scenario.

For the sake of the country, let’s hope this RNZ poll is another outlier. It should be pointed out, though, that this poll was conducted using online panels, with no random phone calls to potential voters.

Advance voting began this week with some extraordinary claims of “voter suppression” because some polling stations weren’t open on Labour Day and because voter enrolment had closed last Sunday night. The closing of the rolls is worth commenting on. From what I can find, this is the earliest cut-off for voter registration in our history. Even in the days before advance voting and online registration, you could always make a special vote right up to election day if you weren’t enrolled by the cut-off date. Up until 2017, the enrolment period closed the day before the election, and in 2020 and 2023, enrolment and voting could take place on Election Day itself. This time there’s no chance if you didn’t make the cut by 25 October, not even if you turn 18 between now and 7 November. If that’s your scenario, you had to have told the Electoral Commission of your circumstances before the cutoff.

The rationale behind this is logical. In the 2023 election period, more than 450,000 people enrolled and voted over the two-week voting period, about a hundred and ten thousand of them on the day itself. Consequently, it took longer to get the final official result, and the Auditor-General found that the volume of work processing the late registrations and votes meant mistakes were made. It was also predicted that if the same pattern of late registrations continued, by 2035 over a million people would enrol and vote during the two weeks of advance voting.

The early cut-off might appear brutal, but there is a practical reason and with technology making the process of enrolment and registration so simple, and with a concerted advertising and public advice campaign, there really is no excuse not to have done it.

As usual, it’s the youth of the country dragging the chain. About 30% of 18-to 24-year-olds are not registered, but maybe we should take the attitude that if they’re not interested in partaking of the democratic process, it’s just better that they don’t.

There wasn’t much in the way of new policy from any party this week. Labour recycled its rental housing policy from before, a policy which is likely once again to drive some landlords out of the market, reduce availability of properties to rent and therefore put up  prices.

Opportunity came up with a daft plan to form a Future Generations Commission which would make recommendations about the future but with no ability to make any recommendations binding on a government. It’s such a nonsensical plan, along with the idea of unelected, appointed – and paid – citizens assemblies to discuss the future and make suggestions to parliament, that it should have just disappeared into the ether. But for whatever reason, the Opportunity leader Qiulae Wong was given long-form interviews on both Q and A on TV1 and on Newstalk ZB on Sunday.

Is there no end to the media love affair with this party?

In fact, independent journalist Chris Lynch from Christchurch wrote to RNZ asking why they had such disproportionate coverage of Qiulae Wong and the Opportunity Party. The RNZ reply was that during the last week the National and Labour parties had twice as much coverage as Opportunity. To which the obvious reply is, well, that means Opportunity’s coverage is really disproportionate. A party polling between 6% and 8% gets half as much coverage as parties polling 3x or 4x that suggests that far too many people at RNZ – and at other news media outlets – are way too fascinated with Opportunity and their very strange ideas. Any party that wants to do politics differently needs to get real.

At least we know for all time that Opportunity won’t be in a government with NZ First. After NZ First candidate and former Defence Minister Ron Mark called out the NZ Defence Force for their diversity, equity and inclusion policy and how it led to the sinking of the 100 million dollar ship, the Manawanui, because the woman commander wasn’t qualified to be in the job, Qiulae Wong said her party would have to seriously reconsider if it could ever work alongside NZ First.

Winston Peters hit back straight away, saying that he’d ruled out that bunch of pinko communists a long time ago. Neither party leader was telling us something we didn’t already know, but it was great to have it confirmed.

Our Contributor

Share This

Leave A Comment