
by Endeavour
Imagine you were a businessman. You’ve spent years building up a successful business empire which your son is lined up to take over when you eventually retire. At the moment, business is thriving, but the uncertainty of the market makes it such that long-term sustained prosperity is never guaranteed. Protecting and advancing your commercial interests requires constant vigilance as you must ensure your empire will remain profitable for the duration of your own career and offer your son a viable career in the future.
One day, someone comes to you with a proposition. They are asking you to invest in a new business opportunity. The idea they are asking you to invest in is an enormous departure from your field of expertise in which you have made your fortune. In addition, they are asking you to invest such a large amount of money that the failure of this investment would bankrupt you. The business concept which they are asking you to take such a risk by investing in is one which has no proven track record of success, and similar ventures from the past have consistently resulted in failure. Maybe there is no market for the product, maybe the market is already too competitive, or maybe the numbers just don’t add up, and it can’t be done profitably.

No one in their right mind would ever agree to such a ridiculous offer. If business is going well and you feel you’ve found a winning formula, your best bet is to stick to what you do best and make minor adjustments in accordance with the changing market. It would be unwise to make a total departure from what is proven to work in favour of something totally unproven. Furthermore, if you had already built up a significant fortune, it would be foolish to gamble it by going all-in on a questionable venture. If you were to take a risk on something new, you’d want to invest a small amount so that, if it didn’t work out, it wouldn’t bankrupt your empire.
While there is clearly no rational basis on which anyone would agree to this proposition, what could lead you to make such a poor investment decision? It could be that the offer was some kind of scam and that you were deceived into accepting it through fraud. Another possibility is that the person asking for the money was a family member or close friend and they used emotional manipulation to guilt you into investing an unreasonable amount in their crackpot idea. The only other possibility would be that you horribly miscalculated and went all-in on a bad deal out of sheer stupidity.
While this may seem needless to say, the socio-political project of multiculturalism currently being enacted in the West mirrors this hypothetical scenario. Western nations in the 20th century could be likened to this theoretical prosperous business empire. By that point, Europe and its extensions in North America and Oceania had spent centuries rapidly advancing and had reached unprecedented levels of civilizational achievement in scientific, cultural, industrial, and military pursuits. Seeing as nations rise and fall regularly throughout history, the custodians of these countries should have understood that maintaining such heights would require constant care and vigilance.

The project of multiculturalism, when it was implemented in the late 20th century, is akin to the theoretical investment proposal outlined earlier. Let’s consider the idea from the standpoint of when it was initiated. The proposition of multiculturalism involves large-scale demographic shifts via mass immigration from the Third World. That is an even greater transformation of Western society than the upheaval brought about by the French Revolution or Russian Revolution. Those revolutions simply brought about changes in governmental structures, albeit radical ones. However, the change remained a matter of policy. Multiculturalism involves the replacement of the very demographic fabric of Western countries.

Not only does multiculturalism propose an enormous departure from what was proven to be an extremely successful societal model, but there is also no scientific, historical or logical reason to believe this change would be beneficial. Up until the middle of the 20th century, it was understood scientifically that heredity had a profound impact on human potential, meaning the ancestry of a population would shape the character of a society. Multiculturalism is predicated on the notion that humans are a blank slate and that heredity has zero influence on their potential, meaning exchanging one population with another wouldn’t lessen the quality of the country they inhabited.
Social science based on this blank slate egalitarian conception of man became popular in the late 20th century, though in the past sixty years, social policy informed by this theory has consistently failed to deliver its promised ends. When the science is not clouded by egalitarian doctrinairism, the results clearly show that heredity does have an impact on one’s capacity for achievement. Metrics such as IQ, academic performance, income, and propensity towards crime have been shown to vary among different ancestral groups. Even when socio-economic factors are controlled for or when twin studies and adoption studies are conducted, the blank slate egalitarian ideological underpinnings of multiculturalism are consistently shown to be scientifically flawed.
Not only does scientific research, when actually conducted honestly, not back up the doctrine of multiculturalism, but historical examples also refute the veracity of its foundational tenets. The mantra “diversity is our strength” could not possibly be further from the truth when considering how diverse societies have fared historically. Ethnic, linguistic, religious, and racial diversity has consistently been a source of conflict throughout history. There are Yugoslavia, South Africa, the British Raj, Austria-Hungary, and countless other historical examples as evidence. In contrast, the countries with the most harmonious histories, such as Iceland, Denmark, or Japan, have been among the most ethnically homogeneous.


Diverse South Africa vs Homogeneous Denmark
Beyond historical examples, the proposition of multiculturalism simply doesn’t make any logical sense on the surface. The root word of “diversity” is “divide.” How could dividing a society possibly make it stronger? Does anyone honestly believe that a country with ten ethnicities, ten languages, and ten religions would be stronger than a country with one ethnicity, one language, and one religion? Even under the most minor of scrutiny, the entire premise for multiculturalism is totally nonsensical.
Lastly, the proposal of multiculturalism as a socio-political project requires an all-in societal investment. It is not a simple policy which can be easily repealed if it is shown not to work. It is a complete restructuring of the demographic make-up of a country. Additionally, multiculturalism requires the reorientation of every cultural norm, law, and public and private institution for the purpose of accommodating this astronomical change. If this experiment were to fail, as all indications suggest it would, it would be irreversible because it would have literally altered the very DNA of any country which implemented it.
Some may argue that new ideas always receive push-back before they are successful, that a winning formula now might not always be so in the future, and that change and innovation are necessary to prevent stagnation. This is applicable to both business and broader society. This is why businesses do a risk-reward analysis before pursuing any potential opportunity. The benefit of success must outweigh the consequences of potential failure to make a risky investment worth making.

With multiculturalism, the risk is the future of your entire country. The purported reward is just shallow cultural novelties like greater culinary variety or vague economic incentives which never seem to materialise. So, the potential risk associated with multiculturalism utterly dwarfs any supposed benefit. It is highly questionable that it is even possible to make multiculturalism work, but even if there were a way, the opportunity cost of restructuring all of society to accommodate the project for such minimal positives is simply not worth the effort. From the perspective of a homogenous and prosperous Western country as they existed as recently as the late 20th century, there is no logical reason to embark on this socio-political project at all.
It may also be argued that it is not about the tangible benefits, but that the West has a moral obligation to enact multiculturalism. Again, no business would ever function like that. If someone came to you asking for an unreasonably large investment in a blatantly flawed business idea, you are not morally obliged to bankrupt yourself in order to avoid hurting their feelings by declining. Likewise, a country is not morally obliged to worsen its own standard of living by implementing disastrous social policy no matter how many ad hominem platitudes are levelled against it by bad actors.
Some could also take exception to evaluating social policy as if it were a commercial enterprise. If there is anything wrong with the analogy, it is that the political decisions which determine the direction of a country should be made with a far greater degree of care than those of financial investments. After all, money is the only thing at stake with the latter. With the former, it is the future of your society, something which should be treated with the same care one would give their own child. In the same sense that you don’t throw a child off a tenth-floor balcony to see if they can fly, you don’t gamble with the future of your society on a crackbrained social experiment.
Nevertheless, the highly developed nations of Europe and the European-derived nations in North America and Oceania did choose to enact such a program in the late 20th century. The results have been as bad as could be expected. How was such a catastrophically bad decision made? The answer is the same as what would impel one to make the hypothetical investment described earlier. It was partly through fraud. Those who pushed multiculturalism had a conflict of interest. They were foreigners with ulterior ethnic agendas, selfish profiteers with a materialistic economic incentive, or just resentful misanthropes who wanted to ruin a healthy and stable society. It was also partly through emotional manipulation. A narrative indicting the West’s historic success as illegitimate and immoral was formed, which brought multiculturalism about through emotional blackmail. Lastly, the decision was also partly a function of just downright, braindead, unthinking stupidity.

Yet that bad decision was made all the same, so what can be done about it now? For a solution, let’s revisit that same scenario outlined at the beginning of this essay. Imagine you made this horrible investment in this hypothetical situation. Whether it was through deception, manipulation, or just plain idiocy, you agreed to this terrible deal, and your once successful business empire is now hemorrhaging money. You are now left with only half of the fortune you had before making such an ill-advised decision, and you are worried that, at this rate, you will have nothing left to pass on to your son. What should you do now?
A blunder frequently made in business is when one continues to pursue a patently unsuccessful venture on the pretence that they have already spent too much money on it to give up. This faulty reasoning is known as the sunk cost fallacy. When deciding where to invest money, future profit should be the only consideration. It is natural for one to have an emotional attachment to the losses they have incurred in the past. However, once that money has been lost, it is sunk cost and should not be taken into consideration when deciding where money should be spent in the future.

There’s a saying in business, “Don’t throw good money after bad.” If a venture has turned into a money pit with no indication that it will turn a profit, there’s no sense in wasting even more money trying in vain to recoup what you’ve lost. Doing so will only bleed you dry of cash. The correct decision is to cut your losses and move on. Knowing you made a terrible mistake which has cost you half your life’s work would be immensely painful, but throwing away the other half chasing after that sunk cost would make your situation twice as bad. Get your money out, salvage what you can, and start to rebuild with what you have left.
The predictable failure of the multicultural project has put the West in a massive sunk cost fallacy. Continued devotion to such an ideology is only going to make the problem worse and worse. Though half of Western civilisation has been poured down the drain in pursuit of this egalitarian delusion, there is no sense in pouring the other half down too. First, an admission must be made that the past sixty years of social policy were a mistake and the societal efforts put towards this experiment are sunk cost that will not come back. Next, such foolhardy policies must be abandoned, and a new order which is in line with scientific honesty, historical precedents, human nature, and common sense must be established. Once that is done, this mishap of an era can be written off, and the rebuilding process can begin.
Originally published on Royal Endeavour.
