
by Nathan Smith
The best thing about this election is that we get to see the results of arguably the most important political experiment of our time. Can the “right” demonstrate discipline?
What happens on the day won’t be terribly interesting. No matter who wins, the civil service will continue to run this country, far beyond the reach of the average voter. Elections are a bit like waves on the surface while down at the seafloor, where all the real power lies, life stays perfectly calm with barely a tremor.
Having said that, I have enjoyed watching the coordinated push on the “right” to use strategic voting to re-elect the so-called “right bloc”: National, ACT and NZ First. Your mileage may vary on how “right wing” any of these political parties truly are. But these days, any party that is “not-left” can reasonably be grouped together.
The first thing to point out about this “right bloc,” however, is that it proves MMP has failed. The entire point of MMP was to shatter the dominance of the two-party structure of Labour (left) and National (right) by introducing minor parties that could reflect different concentrations and nuances of the left and right. MMP promised to increase the surface area of possible politics, giving people more options to vote for parties that were closer to their chosen philosophies and principles.
Yet anyone with half a brain cell knew it was inevitable that MMP would devolve back into a two-party system. But not because “left and right” are natural opposites. Rather, MMP was doomed from the start because it wasn’t linked with a reformation of the media at the same time. The media is not structured for nuance. The media is structured for binaries. That’s why you almost never hear about Asian crime. The media only knows how to discuss “black” and “white” crime, and since the Asians didn’t pick one of these colours, the media doesn’t know how to talk about them. So it rarely does.
You think I’m joking? Look at any story at random. Notice how it starts with a claim (protagonist) and offers a bit of background, before the journalist immediately – almost reflexively – does their “due diligence” by adding a comment from someone with a counterclaim (antagonist). This is the basic structure of news writing.
An editor will never allow a story to be published if it contains just one source or voice. Journalists are trained to “get the other side of the story” from the first day they pick up a pen. Everything else is derisively called “public relations” or the more sinister “propaganda.” When you and I come to read these stories that are always structured as a binary, our minds will be trained to think in binaries, too. This isn’t a giant conspiracy. All journalists are lazy, and their incentives are based on clicks (advertising). So, the easiest way to get eyeballs is to set up a simplified, primeval drama of “two sides.” The “independent media” is even more guilty of this than their mainstream peers.
With a media structured in this way, it was guaranteed that MMP would devolve into “left bloc” versus “right bloc.” It didn’t even take 30 years. Everyone pretty much knew what the score was from the first MMP election. You either voted for the left parties, or you voted for the right parties. The 2026 election now calls these “blocs,” but the dynamic is old. Democracy is the lowest common denominator. And the lowest common denominator is binary. You get the system you deserve, I guess.
This inescapable binary has given us an intriguing experiment for 2026.
As I’ve said before, there is only one “left.” It is a political mistake of gigantic proportions to think you can support a “moderate left” to slow down the advance of leftism. Every leftist knows any support for a leftist group, no matter how cuddly, green and friendly it might appear, is ultimately support for the world-eating blob of communism (or “progressivism,” “socialism” or “wokeism”; doesn’t matter what name you use, it’s all the same thing).
However, in politics there are many “rights.” This is a conspiracy, by the way. The explicit story of the 20th century is one long project of splintering of the political “right” into a million pieces. After WWII, it became essentially illegal to operate politics from the “right.” Even China, which is a clearly fascist country today, knows the score. The Chinese Communist Party is anything but communist, yet it is smart enough to understand that success is a game of branding. And it has gotten away with pretending to be de jure communist, while operating de facto fascist, for 100 years. Clever.
The reason for this is that while it is illegal to be politically “right,” it is much harder to change what is on people’s hearts. Some folks are just born with rightist tendencies. In fact, these gene-deep sentiments were the reason the communists would kill large swathes of people whenever they took power. The logic was horrific but sound. If private property was the root of evil, then anyone whose mind naturally defaulted to creating property should be removed from the gene pool. Remove the genes, remove the desire for private property. Humans were seen as vessels of an enemy idea, and only by destroying those vessels could the idea also be destroyed.
Thankfully, it didn’t quite work out for the communists, and many people still have those inborn desires for things like private property. Those people tend to be genetically predisposed to supporting rightist politics. Unfortunately, it has been hair-pullingly difficult to coordinate such people into any kind of collective political action.
The reason it is difficult is that leftism’s greatest weapon against those on the “right” has been to feed them the poison of individualism. The Boomers sucked on this poison perhaps more than any generation, but it has infected every demographic since WWII. To those on the “right,” individualism is an attractive idea because it sounds sweet and lovely. But individualism turns people into cats, and it is impossible to herd cats. By worshipping individualism, the “right” has been effectively contained for decades and poses no threat to the leftist regime. Again, this is all by design.
On the other hand, the left is extremely adept at coordination. It has thousands of names for when it becomes a mass of political energy, ranging from “proletariat” and “oppressed” to “minorities” and “LGBTQ+”. Leftism, equality and homogeneity are synonyms. This is the philosophy of the blob. A blob acts as one. A blob can be given directions. A blob can become a vote bank. And a vote bank is the path to power in a democracy.
Once you have solved the game of democracy, the only task remaining is to ensure that your enemy can’t solve it as well. The last thing a blob wants is to compete with a rival blob. Much better if the enemy thinks of itself as a series of unconnected individuals.
That’s why the 2026 election is so interesting.
I don’t agree with the idea of strategic voting. If you want to solve the game of democracy, you just need to pick a leader and then do exactly what he says. Be a blob. Become a vote bank. What intrigues me about strategic voting in 2026 is that it shows that the “right” might be finally ready to actually play the game of democracy properly.
I don’t know what will happen on 7 November, but the results are mostly irrelevant at this point. The only thing that matters is if the “right” can follow the formula for winning: discipline + clear vision x strategy = victory. Said differently, can the “right” turn into the right (without scare quotes) and become a true political force? That’s the experiment.
It will still be illegal to be on the political “right” in New Zealand. That won’t change until the US stops being the world hegemon. But there is a lot of wiggle room for rightward movement, shall we say, without triggering clampdowns. You will not be anywhere near “right” enough to take power from the left once and for all. But you can be more “right” than you are, and it starts with learning how to be disciplined and follow a leader.
If the 2026 election can show that the “right” can be coordinated, think about what other kinds of victories it could achieve.
Now you understand why the leftist system seems so worried about strategic voting.
Originally published on The Good Oil.
