
by Rachel Stewart
I remember the interview well.
It’s 1983, I’m 21, and a seemingly endless succession of young men parade into the waiting room – some of whom I know, and who are freezing workers – get called in, and sometime later parade out again. I sit for hours wondering when it’s going to be my turn. They saved me ‘til last.
The room was large and modern. Three men sat at an elevated table and peered down at me. The questions were essentially variations on a theme. That theme was “but why do you want to drive trains?”
They were couched in different ways. “Are you afraid of the dark?” or “You do realise you’ll be working alone with one other person – a male – at all hours of the night and day?” or “How will you cope when you run over an animal, or a person?
There was no discussion around the fact that I held a Private Pilot’s Licence and had been flying gliders since I was sixteen, or had grown up on a farm driving tractors, trucks, motorbikes, and anything else I could get my hands on. I also noted that the other interviews had run at around the 20-minute mark. Mine was well over an hour.
As I was leaving, I thanked them before indulging in a small parting remark. I said, “If I don’t get accepted to loco school, I’ll be curious as to why.” They looked at each other and nodded.
The letter on NZ Railways letterhead arrived about a week later. I was in. As far as I’m aware, I am the first female to ever get the chance to step on the footplate – provided I completed the 13-week training and passed the associated engineering and signal exams by no less than 90%
Oh, but I had to prove that I could couple a locomotive to a wagon on my own first. To do that requires a steel coupler, which is exceedingly heavy.
So, I drove to Palmerston North, was shown how to do it, and then, using my knees and thighs to help steady it, put the pin through, and boom. I drove home before the bruising appeared.
I later discovered no male was asked to do the same – I get that men are stronger without a doubt, but it was very fiddly – but not once in my entire driving career did I ever have to couple the locomotive to a wagon or train. Because that’s what the shunters do.
Needless to say, that was the beginning of a memorable life chapter. I learned how to drive both freight and passenger trains, sure. But arguably the even bigger lesson involved human nature.
Many men simply never accepted my employment in what they saw as “man’s job” and showed their malice in ways designed to sabotage. Others became more like big brothers who went out of their way to protect me. Maybe two or three treated me as an absolute equal while working together managing that thundering hunk of moving metal. I’ve never forgotten them.
You know, the bumper stickers saying ‘Girls Can Do Anything’ were just starting to appear in 1983. I thought those were stupid because it was self-evident. Despite that, I seriously doubt my employment was anything resembling today’s DEI hire. I know I earned that job, and that I did it well.
It is possible that it was around the beginnings of ‘affirmative action,’ and they thought I might be a reasonable bet to take on. But it was far from today’s DEI cult – albeit it was likely the beginnings of the ‘slippery slope’.
The sinking of the Royal NZ Navy’s HMNZS Manawanui quickly became the poster child of the anti-DEI movement. In their world, Commander Yvonne Gray is both a vagina-haver AND a lesbian; therefore, she just HAS to be a DEI hire, AND it’s her fault for the sinking – all of which was decided prior to any investigation, report, or any detailed information coming about the cause. They started their very public screeching before the ship had even settled on the ocean floor.
Those critics were misusing DEI as a way to undermine the Commander’s competence – and they knew it – notwithstanding that the Navy has flagrantly celebrated their own institutional fabulousness by widely publicising their employment of female ship staff, which no doubt invited an inquisition given the sinking.
As if Yvonne Gray didn’t have any prior experience at all, nor had to pass any test or exam exactly as the men must. They just chucked her up on the bridge and said, “Go for it, baby!” Give me a break.
Based on the official findings of the Royal New Zealand Navy (RNZN) Court of Inquiry, the sinking was attributed to operational human error and systemic Navy failures in training, certification, and risk management—not Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies.
When the Manawanui deployed to Samoa, it was sailing with 20 “personnel deficiencies”. The Navy’s shore-based command granted waivers that allowed the ship to operate despite the captain and 19 crew members lacking vessel-specific certifications (“platform endorsements”) and without completing full seaworthiness workups. So Captain Gray wasn’t the only one without that specific endorsement.
While online commentators and social media posts frequently labelled Commander Yvonne Gray a “DEI hire” due to her gender and sexual orientation, the formal military investigation and New Zealand’s defence leadership found no evidence linking her appointment to diversity quotas.
The direct cause of the grounding was a series of errors on the bridge. Crew members failed to disengage the ship’s autopilot as it approached a reef, mistakenly believing the vessel’s lack of response to steering commands was a thruster control failure.
Following the inquiry, the New Zealand Defence Force charged Gray (a female) and two other officers who were on the bridge (males) with negligence, alleging gaps in risk planning and supervision—including allegations that Gray was absent from the bridge while the ship was operating close to a known reef.
So those crew members who failed to disengage the ship’s autopilot were men. DEI had nothing to do with them, now did it?
And as with the Lear Jet that nose-dived and crashed last month in Florida, the online commentary was brutal about the female co-pilot while the Captain actually flying the plane was entirely left alone.
Somehow, once again, the young female co-pilot was instantly dismissed as a product of DEI when, in fact, she was more than qualified to co-pilot that aircraft. When training to be a pilot, she was at the top of her class and was properly certified for the position, having flown over 1300 flight hours. Aviation safety experts also confirmed that she had earned her seat through proper hours and training.
So DEI denigration, at this juncture, is often a red herring. But for what?
I don’t want to use the ‘M’ word, but it appears unavoidable. When endless screeds of men on social media state straight-faced that women’s lack of spatial awareness is proven – PROVEN, I TELL YOU – to be inferior to men’s, you know it’s misogyny.
There are many studies that have disproven that widely accepted trope. Yet when a few women push back against the screechers – me among them – we are attacked in a way that we know in our bones is just down-home women-hatred. Ask us how we know? That’s a book in itself.
What also disappoints is how many men run cover for the men abusing us. I was told by various non-de-plume neck beards that I was “mentally ill” for being a “dyke,” and that same “mental illness” in Yvonne Gray is what sunk the Manawanui.
Yet, apart from one or two exceptions. other normally ‘good’ men said nothing or just said, “They’re only joking. They’d make fun of a male captain just the same if he sunk a boat!” Yeah, nah. I could show you receipts that would make your hair curl, and frizz, and fall out.
Maybe they/you don’t see female confidence on display that much because women, in the main, don’t tend to be attracted to driving trains, flying planes, or captaining ships?
It’s kind of like women’s sports not getting the TV ratings because (men often used to say) it’s not that interesting to them compared to male sports. That is, until the media started televising it anyway, and now the ratings are sound – from both men and women. Doing nothing is an endless loop of self-fulfilling prophecy if you’re not careful.
And look, the rabid DEI push has set up a narrative where now every man, some women, and their dogs believe that every female, dark-skinned person, or dwarf has not got through on merit. That’s the problem with promoting (sometimes fake) diversity, equity, and inclusion. Nobody trusts it. So, the end result of DEI is a vicious backlash. We are in that phase now. But we must retain our critical thinking skills.
And I mostly disagree with the movement, but I can still see far enough through the frenetic knee-jerking to know the difference between hating the ‘diversity’ crusade and picking on every woman you assume is aligned with them simply by earning her place in what was once a traditional male job.
Let me tell you this. Forty years ago I earned my train driving ticket. I had to put up with a lot of sexist bullshit, but I did it. Yvonne Gray earned her job too – just like the two other men who were court-martialled – but was actually let down by systemic failures from within the Royal NZ Navy. And Nathalia Filgueiras more than earned her pilot stripes before her sad death.
And when the armchair admirals tell us we’re just not spatially capable, or are a product of DEI solely, or whatever’s code for “get back in the kitchen”, we tend to get a bit testy. Some of us are simply good at what we do. Live with it without turning it into a conspiracy every time something goes wrong.
Because when men are involved in derailing a train, crashing a plane, or sinking a ship, we notice these ridiculous, sexualised conversations never ever happen. In other words, we see you.
Listen to the full episode of Riding Shotgun.
