
The Overhang Debate: David Farrar’s Objections, and Why I Disagree
by Claire Deeks, Co-Founder, RCR Media and Voices For Freedom
Let’s start with the arithmetic, because everything turns on it.
National could win more electorate seats than its party vote entitles it to. If that happens, it keeps those seats, receives no list MPs, and Parliament grows to accommodate the overhang. In those circumstances, shifting party votes from National to ACT or NZ First can increase the coalition’s overall representation without reducing National’s electorate seats.
If National is not in an overhang, the calculation changes. Switching party votes will generally redistribute seats within the coalition rather than increase its total representation, potentially costing National experienced list MPs.
So the central question is how likely National is to overhang.
And this is where my disagreement with political commentator and pollster David Farrar gets interesting.
In a recent interview with Paul Brennan on RCR, David explained why he opposes the organised overhang strategy being promoted ahead of the 2026 election. He’s one of the country’s most respected pollsters and, like me, wants the current coalition returned to government. His objections deserve a hearing.
On the central question, David and I agree.
His own modelling suggests an overhang on the right is reasonably likely. He expects some overhang on the left too, meaning the net advantage may be smaller than the total number of additional National seats. Even so, he says: “I think it’s more likely that the net overhang favours the centre-right.”
On David’s own assessment, an overhang could make the difference between the coalition returning to government and losing office, and he accepts it as a potential additional pathway to victory.
Our disagreement isn’t really about whether an overhang could benefit the coalition. It’s really about whether voters should deliberately pursue that opportunity.
I believe they should. Here’s why.
Legitimacy and backlash
David’s main objection is that engineering an overhang could undermine confidence in the result, particularly if it lets a coalition govern with fewer party votes than its opponents. As he puts it: “There could be more than a backlash. I think there will be some people who will call the government illegitimate.” And: “I desperately want the government to get back, but I want that because more people voted for National, Act and NZ First than the other four”.
And while I respect that preference, it has to be pointed out that these rules have been in place for 30 years. Overhang is not a loophole; it is how MMP was designed to treat electorate seats. Nobody called the 2023 Parliament illegitimate when the Maori Party’s electorate wins produced an overhang, did they?
Think of Olympic race walking. The technique looks odd, but it is within the rules, so nobody calls the winner a cheat. Nor do they call the coach a cheat for teaching the whole team. The technique is just as lawful when it is organised as when one athlete stumbles on it. That seems to be the heart of David’s objection: not that voters use the rules, but that someone explains them and encourages people to use them well. I can’t see why informing voters is the problem.
Critics will call any government they lose to illegitimate. They do that already. We should not shape our votes around what our opponents might say.
David also fears an engineered overhang could lead to US-style political division, with opponents refusing to accept the government’s legitimacy. But political division in New Zealand didn’t begin with Vote Smart 2026. We have lived through years of intense polarisation, particularly over Covid policies, mandates, lost livelihoods and the treatment of people who questioned government decisions. Trust was severely damaged long before anyone began discussing an overhang.
Nor do I think National’s very public opposition to the strategy has helped. Framing a lawful feature of MMP as though deliberately using it is somehow improper only adds to the controversy.
Of course I want election results to be respected. But I am not persuaded that we should abandon a potentially advantageous, lawful electoral strategy because the losing side might be unhappy with the result. Political division already exists – we didn’t create it by explaining how MMP works.
Losing ministers
David’s second objection is that encouraging National supporters to give their party votes to ACT or NZ First could cost National experienced list MPs, including ministers such as Nicola Willis, Chris Bishop and Paul Goldsmith.
He asks: “Can you tell me who’s number 15 on the ACT list or the NZ First list?” He then contrasts losing three experienced National ministers with gaining three “lowly-ranked backbench MPs”.
Of course, National’s falling party-vote support has already put those list seats at risk, whether or not anyone encourages vote splitting. But returning to number 15: it is a misleading comparison when discussing the experience of a future government’s ministers.
The current government has just 27 ministers across all three parties: 18 from National, five from ACT and four from NZ First. Even if ACT and NZ First substantially increased their parliamentary representation, that doesn’t mean everyone entering Parliament from their lists becomes a minister. If National retained 15 ministerial positions in a similarly sized ministry, for example, that would leave only 12 between the other two parties.
And look at the people actually available.
NZ First already has experienced ministers in Winston Peters, Shane Jones, Casey Costello and Mark Patterson. Beyond them are Alfred Ngaro, a former National minister; Michael Laws, a former MP and mayor; Harete Hipango-Brownlie, a former National MP; Craig Stobo, with extensive financial and governance experience; and Taine Randell, a former All Black captain and businessman.
ACT likewise has experienced ministers in David Seymour, Nicole McKee, Andrew Hoggard and Karen Chhour, alongside MPs Todd Stephenson, Simon Court and Laura McClure. And, of course, there’s Paul Henry at number four on ACT’s list. Whatever one thinks of him, he hardly lacks experience or the ability to hold his own.
So why are we discussing number 15 rather than the people who might realistically be considered for ministerial positions?
Nor should we assume every National minister potentially at risk has been an overwhelming success. Nicola Willis, particularly exposed given her list-only position, has faced criticism from both left and right over her economic management. I certainly wouldn’t be crying into my cornflakes if she failed to return.
Then there’s Chris Bishop. By many accounts, he’s a hardworking MP. He’s not a personal favourite of mine, given his comments and conduct during the Covid years, but credit where it’s due. With National’s list prospects uncertain, winning Hutt South may be his most realistic route back to Parliament.
Interestingly, Winston Peters has just taken the unusual step of endorsing Bishop for the electorate, while NZ First’s own candidate, Alistair Boyce, is concentrating on the party vote. It’s a striking example of strategic voting being used to retain precisely the sort of experienced National MP David is worried about losing.
Of course, if National would otherwise receive list seats, moving party votes away could cost it experienced people. David is right about that risk. But if National is already in overhang, its list-only MPs cannot return through the list. The question is what representation the different voting scenarios would actually produce, not simply whether National has ministers worth retaining.
Protecting National’s future at the expense of this election?
David also worries that if National returns no list MPs, it could permanently weaken the party’s ability to attract talented future candidates. As he puts it: “If they get no list MPs this election, I think it permanently weakens them.”
Perhaps he’s right. But what is the priority here? Keeping the coalition in government at this election, or protecting National’s ability to recruit list candidates three years from now?
Candidate recruitment and succession are ultimately National’s responsibility. David himself acknowledges this problem could arise regardless of our campaign, given National’s declining party-vote support. It seems extraordinary to suggest that voters should put National’s future recruitment prospects ahead of their immediate electoral priorities. That’s an argument for protecting the National Party, not necessarily the coalition government.
And it is worth remembering that National’s declining party-vote support is what has created the possibility of a substantial overhang in the first place. It is not the responsibility of those explaining the electoral rules to protect National from the consequences of its own political performance.
A stronger NZ First or ACT may be exactly what voters want
David also argues that National, ACT and NZ First are not interchangeable. Their relative numbers affect the policies and direction of a future government.
On this, I agree entirely.
Plenty of voters want the coalition returned but are dissatisfied with National’s performance. They want NZ First and ACT to have greater influence. For them, a stronger coalition partner isn’t an unfortunate side effect. It’s a welcome outcome.
David himself acknowledges that all three parties are preferable to a left-wing government. “Absolutely,” he says. So surely the first priority is ensuring there is a coalition government to influence in the first place?
If National is in an overhang, the strategy may strengthen the coalition overall. If it isn’t, voters need to understand that switching party votes may instead change the balance within it. Either way, National’s interests and the coalition’s interests are not necessarily identical.
The arms race
David warns that if the right organises around an overhang, the left will respond in kind, turning MMP into a contest of split-ticket tactics.
But the left has already adopted such a strategy. In August, the Maori Party openly urged supporters to give its candidates their electorate votes while directing their party votes to Labour or the Greens, potentially creating an overhang. This follows its 2023 result, in which six electoral victories produced a two-seat overhang.
So why should voters on the right be discouraged from understanding the same electoral rules? Asking one side to stand still while the other makes deliberate use of MMP is not principle. It’s unilateral disarmament.
If people dislike the outcome, the remedy is to change the rules through Parliament. Until then, both sides operate under the same electoral system.
Uncertainty
David points out that the outcome is hard to predict. We don’t know exactly how the 64 general and seven Maori electorates will fall, how big any overhang will be, or how the two sides will net out.
All true. But no election strategy comes with a guarantee. Uncertainty is a reason to understand the numbers, seat by seat, not a reason to ignore an opportunity his own modelling says is real.
Accident or design
David seems more comfortable with an overhang that happens by accident than with one voters choose. I find that a strange line to draw. The seats are allocated by the same rules either way. Whether voters reach an outcome by luck or by understanding makes no difference to its legitimacy, only to how much scrutiny it attracts. That is a question of perception, and the best answer to it is openness.
The last few years have left many New Zealanders wary of being told what they may and may not do. Telling them not to use their two votes as the law allows will not help.
Taking an election seriously
I want the right bloc to win this election. I want the coalition returned, and the left kept out of government. And I want it done fairly, openly and within the rules.
David and I share that goal. We differ on method. He would prefer the coalition win on party votes alone, and so would I. But on his own numbers, overhang may decide this election and is more likely to favour our side. Knowing that and choosing to ignore it makes no sense to me.
National is entitled to campaign for every party vote it can get. But National’s interests and the coalition’s interests are not always the same thing. Voters deserve to understand that distinction.
Which brings me to the question of ethics. In the recent leaders’ debate, both Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins agreed that deliberately engineering an overhang amounted to “cheating”. How so?
The rules have been there for 30 years. Voters have two votes, and they’re entitled to understand how to use them. There is nothing inherently improper about making an informed, deliberate choice within those rules.
Of course, people can disagree about whether the strategy is wise, fair or desirable. That’s a legitimate debate. But I do question the ethics of portraying voter education and the deliberate use of lawful electoral rules as somehow untoward.
Frankly, I’m sick and tired of people not being told the whole truth. Voters deserve to know how the system actually works, what opportunities it presents and what risks different choices carry. Not simply the version that happens to suit a particular political party.
Understanding the rules is being informed. Explaining them is empowering voters. And making deliberate use of them is exercising the democratic rights we all have.
A general election is a serious occasion – and we are taking it seriously.
